Home Boulder's Best Spots Where to Buy Thanksgiving Pie (and Cake!) in the Boulder Area

Where to Buy Thanksgiving Pie (and Cake!) in the Boulder Area

by Rachel Daly
thanksgiving pie boulder

Thanksgiving is almost two weeks away. For the perfect Thanksgiving dessert, check out this comprehensive list of small local bakeries that are serving up delicious Thanksgiving desserts in and around Boulder. Your family and friends will thank you!

Beehold Cakes

Thanksgiving Pie Boulder

Photo Courtesy Beehold Cakes

Beehold Cakes delivers cakes right to your door! For the holidays, Beehold Cakes is offering Gingersnap Cake and Chocolate Peppermint Bliss, in addition to the bakery’s classic favorites, Bananas Foster, Snickerdoodle and Salted Caramel Chocolate.

Allow 24 – 48 hours for order processing. Order your Thanksgiving dessert from Beehold Cakes here. Beehold Cakes delivers to the Denver/Boulder/Longmont area for a small delivery fee.

Boulder Baked

Boulder Baked offers a variety of pies, including Pumpkin Pie, Apple Pie, and Cherry Pie. In addition to traditional Thanksgiving pies, Boulder Baked offers cream pies, as well as crisps, cakes and cookies, including vegan and gluten free recipes.

Allow 24 – 48 hours notice for full pies. Boulder Baked is located at 1911 Broadway, Boulder, Colorado 80302, but also offers delivery service. Order your Thanksgiving pies and desserts from Boulder Baked here.

Button Rock Bakery

thanksgiving pie boulder

Photo Courtesy Button Rock Bakery

Button Rock Bakery in Lafayette is offering Thanksgiving Pies as well as breakfast boxes to make your Thanksgiving day extra delicious. Button Rock has all the traditional flavors, including cherry, apple, peach and pumpkin, as well as key lime, lemon meringue, and strawberry rhubarb.

Call Button Rock Bakery at (303) 926-1676 to order your Thanksgiving dessert! Button Rock Bakery is located at 1377 Forest Park Cir Suite 102, Lafayette, CO 80026,

Eats and Sweets

thanksgiving pie Boulder

Photo Courtesy Eats and Sweets

Eats and Sweets in Lafayette features a Thanksgiving menu including apple, pumpkin and pear pie, as well as cheesecakes and gluten free options. The bakery is also offering Thanksgiving quiche.

Order your Thanksgiving pies from Eats and Sweets by Monday, November 20 by calling (303) 665-3287. Eats and Sweets is located at 401 S Public Rd, Lafayette, CO 80026.

The Huckleberry

thanksgiving pie boulder

Photo Courtesy The Huckleberry

The Huckleberry in Louisville is offering its Thanksgiving holiday pies, including cherry, pumpkin and apple, as well as gluten free and vegan options.

Order your holiday pies from the Huckleberry by calling (303) 666-8020. The Huckleberry is located at 700 Main St, Louisville, CO 80027.

Kim and Jake’s Cakes

thanksgiving pie boulder

Kim and Jake’s Cakes of Boulder is offering a Thanksgiving menu including fall cake flavors like ginger molasses, pumpkin and orange cake, as well as bread pudding, cinnamon rolls and pumpkin cake bars.

Order your Thanksgiving cakes and sweets by Saturday, November 18 by phone at (303) 499-9126. Kim and Jake’s Cakes is located at 641 S Broadway, Boulder, CO 80305.

La Momo Maes Bakery

thanksgiving pie boulder

La Momo Maes Bakery in Longmont is offering a variety of Thanksgiving pies, including apple, cherry, blueberry, pecan and more! Gluten free options, as well as many other dessert options are available.

Order Thanksgiving pies by calling (303) 834-8502. La Momo Maes Bakery is located at 900 S Hover St unit f, Longmont, CO 80501.

Lucky’s Bakehouse & Creamery

thanksgiving pie Boulder

Photo Courtesy Lucky’s Bakehouse and Creamery

Lucky’s Bakehouse & Creamery is featuring a variety of Thanksgiving desserts, including gingersnap pumpkin pie, salted caramel apple pie, lemon almond ricotta cake and more.

Order from the Thanksgiving menu by calling (720) 596-4905. Lucky’s Bakehouse & Creamery is located at 3960 Broadway, Boulder, CO 80304.

My Mom’s Pie

thanksgiving pie boulder

Photo Courtesy My Mom’s Pie

My Mom’s Pie in Niwot is taking orders for Thanksgiving desserts, including pumpkin praline, bourbon pecan, wild blueberry, raspberry rhubarb pie and so many more!

Order your pie today by phone at (303) 652-6667. My Mom’s Pie is located at 201 Murray St C, Niwot, CO 80503.

Shamane’s Bake Shoppe

thanksgiving pies boulder

Photo Courtesy Shamane’s Bake Shoppe

Shamane’s Bake Shoppe offers a variety of fruit and cream pies, from cherry vanilla bean and chocolate pecan to classic pumpkin. Shamane’s Thanksgiving menu also includes savory pot pies, quiche, brioche rolls and more!

Shamane’s Bake Shoppe is accepting Thanksgiving pie orders by phone at (303) 417-9338. Shamane’s Bake Shoppe is located at 2825 Wilderness Pl #800, Boulder, CO 80301.

T&Cakes

thanksgiving pie boulder

Photo Courtesy T&Cakes

T&Cakes in Boulder is offering a variety Thanksgiving pies and cakes, including pumpkin custard, chocolate bourbon pecan pie, apple spice cake and pumpkin salted caramel cake.

T&Cakes is accepting Thanksgiving orders by phone at (720) 406-7548. T&Cakes is located at 1932 14th St, Boulder, CO 80302.

Walnut Cafe

thanksgiving pie boulder

Photo Courtesy Walnut Cafe

Walnut Cafe in Boulder is known for its delicious pie by the slice. For Thanksgiving, Walnut Cafe offers a limited number of whole pie orders.

Order your whole pie from Walnut Cafe before they are gone by phone at (720) 406-7548. Walnut Cafe is located at 3073 Walnut St, Boulder, CO 80301.

About Rachel Daly

I am Rachel, Boulder writer, mother and animal lover. It is my passion to explore Boulder and to share what I've learned with you! My husband, Jeremiah Daly, is a local Realtor and neighborhood expert. We live in the Boulder foothills with our two young daughters.

View All Posts

You may also like

Leave a Comment